Monday, January 25, 2016

Marvin Minsky, 1927-2016


Prof. Marvin Lee Minsky, or just Marvin to those who knew him, died last night.  We have lost one of the great humans of our time, perhaps of all time.  A humble, brilliant, passionate man, with a blazing intellect and an amazing zen, a childlike curiosity, Marvin pioneered much of the early work in AI, together with John McCarthy, Herb Simon, and Allen Newell and others.  He opened our eyes to much that was new, and he and his academic progeny have shaped a lot of what we know about AI today.

With a grad school recommendation letter of all of a single line, Marvin changed my life.  And his work, his teachings, his ways of exploring the unknown, his ability to span and to combine several widely varied disciplines, have been a great lesson to me, a source of great inspiration over more than 25 years, from my graduate studies, to our recent work on AI, both at Infosys and with OpenAI.  Indeed when I started my AI lecture recently for Infoscions, not happy with any of the recent work I saw, I went back to a paper Marvin wrote before I was born ("Steps Towards Artificial Intelligence").

As sad as I am, and countless others are at his passing, perhaps even sadder is his recent statement, on the current state of the work in AI, at a time when we hear about AI and its impact on our world and our lives all around us.  Last week I was in Davos at the World Economic Forum's mtg, and AI, and its feared impact on people's lives, and jobs, was the talk of the town.  I hosted a panel with some key experts as well, to try and add something hopefully thoughtful, to all these voices, but perhaps just added more to the noise, and all along I kept thinking of how Marvin would have reacted to all that sound, all those alarms.  Perhaps he'd have chuckled, before unleashing a typical Marvin zinger that would put things in perspective, and yet enlighten.  Despite the widespread interest in, and hype around, AI, we are nowhere close to implementing many of Marvin's ideas, including his work in the society of mind, which he published ~25 years ago.

So in looking back on his life, and reflecting on his passing, perhaps the best we can all resolve to do is to live his dream, his aspiration, of building systems that get ever closer to Artificial Intelligence, but to do so in a way that he would have been proud of; his purposefulness and integrity, his gang of experimenters, his childlike curiosity, his "model railroad club", his instinct to look at things from many different perspectives.  That a purposeful, unencumbered, pursuit of artificial intelligence may in the process get us that much closer to our natural spirituality.

Upon hearing the news of Marvin's passing, Alan Kay, his friend for the last 50 odd years, said to me "... there was no one ever like him."  So true.

R.I.P Marvin.  There was no one ever like you.  We will miss you...

50 comments:

Pushkar Sawant said...

I am a student in India. I was in touch with Marvin Minsky for a number of years over AI research. He was willing to write an enthusiastic recommendation for me for a transfer undergrad admission to the US. (The process didnt work out, for some other local reasons). I couldnt get a heavenly opportunity of a job in his group owing to lack of funding for his research. The latest with him was that he was willing to write a letter for direct admission to graduate school in the US.

For the last 2 years he went completely out of touch, owing to his health.

A 60-page theoretical research document in the areas of 'Commonsense Knowledge and Reasoning' and 'NLP', unfortunately couldnt reach him.

Anubhav said...

Hi Vishal,

Wanted to drop in a post card to you about a few thoughts about Marvin. If you can help out with your office address, would be happy to write in.

Thx

Unknown said...

Great fan of you sir......hope I'll meet to you one day.
And yes hearty congratulations for your success on INFOSYS.
VERY HAPPY TO HEAR THAT

Prashant Kulkarni said...

Agree with what you said about him. I read about him way back in 1992 when I had purchased a book titled Machinery of the Mind by George Johnson, in which author had given many references to his work.

Prashant
https://ppkya.wordpress.com

MONEY POWER said...

This writting touch my heart even i am frist time hearing about him at this time it is enlightned me the guru bakthi of Mr VISHAL SIKKA that is a great charater of a person who grows fast in life.

MONEY POWER said...

This writting touch my heart even i am frist time hearing about him at this time it is enlightned me the guru bakthi of Mr VISHAL SIKKA that is a great charater of a person who grows fast in life.

Anonymous said...

This article surely helps for all.
Business Software

Rahul John said...

Aryavart Empire


Call +91-8081888555

Website:- http://www.paartharyavartempire.in/

Rahul John said...

supertech crown tower

Call: +91-9210333666
Website:- http://www.supertechcrowntower.in

Rahul John said...

ajnara klock tower


Call: +91-9210333666
Website:- http://www.klocktower.in/

Unknown said...

Informative post you have shared with us.
Modelling Agencies in Mumbai | Celebrity Management Companies | Female Models in Mumbai

Raora Jok said...

You can download any type of crack software from here https://techubi.com/

Unknown said...

I'm happy to get in touch and collaborate.

Vijay said...

My Name Vijay Goulay and Practising astrology from 14 years , Just I was going through your chart where I have got the information from the google 1 June 1967 and assuming 6: 50 am is your birth time ... you are ending period of Kethu Dasha and after this you have Shukra Dasha ( Venus Period ) for 20 years and this is going to be very good ,
15m
Sent

Vijay Goulay
You have faced more hurdles in Ketu dasha and that started from 26/8/2010 to 25/8/2017 ... this will end on 25th august of this month and after that your life will be on fast track no hurdles, my wishes with you...

Rahul said...

Aditya Group has presents Aditya Urban Homes at Aditya World City NH 24 Ghaziabad. Book 1 and 2 bhk apartments on prime location with No Pre-EMI Payment Plan. Call Us: +91-8010 654 321

Rahul said...

Apex The Kremlin in Siddharth Vihar , Ghaziabad launched by Apex Buildcon available 2 BHK BHK Apartments in Apex The Kremlin in Siddharth Vihar with more amenities. Call Us: +91-8010654321

Gramy said...

Magnificent, I am extremely Happy to join this network
I found here exceptionally fascinating and supportive continue sharing
you may likewise like this página web oficial

TeknikoGlobal said...

Thank you for sharing such an informative information with us. Professional Mobile App Development Company in Noida at https://www.teknikoglobal.com/

FAST LOAN OFFER whats-App +918929509036 said...

Dearest Esteems,

We are Offering best Global Financial Service rendered to the general public with maximum satisfaction,maximum risk free. Do not miss this opportunity. Join the most trusted financial institution and secure a legitimate financial empowerment to add meaning to your life/business.

Contact Dr. James Eric Firm via
Email: fastloanoffer34@gmail.com
Whatsapp +918929509036
Best Regards,
Dr. James Eric.
Executive Investment
Consultant./Mediator/Facilitator

awdawd said...

Permainan Sabung Ayam Online di Agen BOLAVITA , dengan minimal deposit hanya Rp 25.000 saja , dan minimal betting hanya Rp 10.000 saja sudah bisa mainkan permainan Sabung Ayam

http://agensabungayam.logdown.com/post/7858473-dosis-pemberian-telur-puyuh-untuk-ayam-bangkok-aduan

Produk Kami Judi Sabung Ayam Online S128, SV388 & KungfuChiken.

https://www.sateayam.vip/
https://m1.hj128.vip/
Daftar Sabung Ayam sv388
Daftar Sabung Ayam Online S128

Agen Sabung Ayam Online Bolavita Banyak Bonus dan Promo Mari Bergabung :

Promo Sabung Ayam Terbaru 8x Win Beruntun.
Bolavita Bisa Deposit Via OVO & GO-Pay.
Sabung Ayam Deposit Via Pulsa XL & TSEL 25rb.

Promo Promo BOLAVITA

Telegram : +62812-2222-995
Wechat : Bolavita
WA : +62812-2222-995
Line : cs_bolavita

NIKE said...

Keep sweet smelling food products in sealed play bazaar satta king containers or in the fridge. Sweet foods can easily attract a vast variety of pests, from rodents to ants. If you do not have enough containers to seal your sugar, cereal and breads you should invest in them. It will cost you a lot less than paying an exterminator.
satta king play bazaar

Rahul said...

ATS Launching Soon Floral Pathways NH24 Ghaziabad
PreLaunch Bookings Open On 1st Come 1st Serve Basis.
Visit: https://propshop.org.in/ats-floral-pathways.php
CallUs: @8010654321

Rahul said...

Arihant Buildcon Builders introduces its latest residential project Arihant Abode in Sector 10 Greater Noida. Click to Contact PROPSHOP Advertiser or Book your Dream Home.
Visit:https://propshop.org.in/arihant-abode.php
CallUs: @7676888000

Rahul said...

A home in the woods, yet in the city” is a perfect way to describe Mahagun Mywoods. Designed by the renowned Hafeez Contractor.
Visit: https://propshop.org.in/mahagun-mywoods.php
CallUs: @7676333222

playbazaar said...

Nice site and visit now- play bazaar satta king

SEMIBOLA SLOT DEPOSIT PULSA TANPA POTONGAN said...

joker123pulsa
deposit pulsa tanpa potongan
deposit pulsa tanpa potongan slot

Raj Maan said...

Lot of great information which can be helpful in some or the other way. Keep updating the blog, 123movies

riya patel said...

I saw this very good post of yours and I liked it very much, I do not know how to praise it, I would just like to say that this post is one of the posts that I like very much and I am very happy to see these posts.
Desi Girls Gurugram
Escort Services in Noida
Gurugram Call Girls Service
Ordinary call girls in Gurugram

Unknown said...

What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much.


Best UI/UX Design Services

Unknown said...

Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work.


Product Development Company

Unknown said...


That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck.

Best Artificial Intelligence Company in Dubai

Plumbing & HVAC Services San Diego said...

Plumbing & HVAC Services San Diego
Air Star Heating guarantees reliability and quality for all equipment and services.
Air Star Heating is specializing in providing top-quality heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and plumbing services to our customers and clients.
Our company is leading the market right now. By using our seamless and huge array of services. Our customers can now have the privilege of taking benefit from our services very easily and swiftly. To cope up with the desires and needs of our clients we have built an excellent reputation. We are already having a huge list of satisfied customers that seem to be very pleased with our services.

Plumbing & HVAC Services in San Diego. Call now (858) 900-9977 ✓Licensed & Insured ✓Certified Experts ✓Same Day Appointment ✓Original Parts Only ✓Warranty On Every Job.
Visit:- https://airstarheating.com

Aditya said...

click on one of the sites below to get a variety of the best tips and tricks in life.

agen togel terpercaya

Nisha nehwal said...

It is very important to have good thoughts in mind to write a beautiful post and your mind seems very clear only then you have written such a beautiful post, this post is worth praising, it will be less than the praise of this post.
bhiwadi escorts
sector 20 escorts girls
escort service gurugram
call girls in gurugram
call girls in gurugram
call girls in gurugram
call girls in gurugram
Hotel Eros Nehru Place Call Girls
Jungle Babbler Escorts
Escorts Service in DLF Phase 5

Aiko said...

PUAS4D-Situs Slot Online Dengan Uang Asli
PUAS4D-Bonus New Member 50%
PUAS4D-Situs Togel ID PRO
PUAS4D-Situs Live Casino ID PRO
PUAS4D-Daftar ID PRO Terpuaskan
PUAS4D-Agent Togel Hongkong
PUAS4D-Agent Togel Singapura
PUAS4D-Agent Togel Sidney
PUAS4D-Agent Togel Malaysia
PUAS4D-Agent Togel Macau

sabresalih said...

This is informative blog i got a valuable information on the post

Torrentz2 Proxy Unblock Torrentz2.eu {Working100%} Latest Sites List

ETTV Proxy Unblockit ETTV & latest Sites {Working 100%}

MagnetDL Proxy Unblock MagnetDL Latest sites List {Working 100%}

isoHunt Proxy Unblock isoHunt Updated Sites list {Working 100%}

Demonoid Proxy Unblock Demoind.pw Proxy {Working 100%} Site List

Health Write For UsSubmit Guest Post on Lifestyle, Beauty, Travel, Health, Fitness

iDope Proxy Unblock idope.se Latest 2022 iDope Proxy List {100% Working}

Unknown said...


Emblix Academy – Digital marketing institute in KPHB, we address all major and minor aspects required for any student’s advancement in digital marketing. Clutch USA named our Digital Marketing Institute the best SEO firm.

The future of digital marketing is promising and full of possibilities.

As a result, skilled digital marketers who can keep up with the rising demand are in high order.
In the Emblix Academy Digital marketing institute in KPHB, you will learn about all the major and minor modules of digital marketing, from Search engine marketing to Social Media Marketing and almost all Tools used for Digital Marketing.
One stop place for all Digital Marketing courses! Emblix Academy is a Team of dedicated Professionals with 12years of experience in various Digital Platforms. We assure to provide the best Digital Marketing courses to enhance your Career.
Certifications

• Search Advertising
• Display Advertising
• Analytics Certification
• Hubspot Certification
• Bing Certification
• Twitter Certification
• Facebook Certification



https://emblixacademy.com/

sabresalih said...

This is valuable information on the post informative blog i got

ExtraTorrent Proxy List of Unblock all Extratorrent Proxy Sites latest

Tamilyogi Proxy Unblock Tamilyogi cc proxy List 2022 Movie Download

List of Unblock Limetorrents Proxy Mirrors sites Limetorrents Proxy

list Unblock Extratorrents Proxy {100% Working Sites} Extratorrent proxy

Unblock Skytorrents.net {100% Working Sites} SkyTorrents Proxy

Activation Free Updated 2022 Microsoft Office 365 Product Key list

Write for us Technology – Submit Guest Post on Business, Mobile, Education Topics

PGsharp Key list Generator PGsharp Free Activation Key 2022

Assignment Prime said...

Nowadays students have so many things to do in their academics. Professors sometimes make the students overburdened with assignments and exam stuff. Assignments require lots of research and writing time too. We have many experts who can help you with assignment writing. Assignment Writing Service Adelaide will really help you to achieve good grades.

Alina jonas said...

Growing lifestyle hazards such as diabetes and obesity, as well as public health awareness, require more effective and efficient therapies. Anticoagulant use and expense have increased dramatically since the advent of NOACs. Anticoagulant production and efficiency are increasing as pharmaceutical and therapeutic industries improve. Anticoagulant sales are increasing as a result of this. COVID-19’s health concerns and threats have prompted increased investment in the anticoagulant business. The government’s increasing healthcare spending, as well as that of important industry players, is a major driving force in the   Anticoagulants Market market.


Also read: Solar Panel Recycling Market , automotive power liftgate market , umbilical cord blood banking market

walid elarawy said...

شركة مكافحة حشرات بطرابلس
شركة تنظيف بطرابلس
شركة صيانة افران الغاز بطرابلس
شركة تسليك مجاري بطرابلس

Essien said...

Oh, what a loss! Big beat! I love this site due to your knowledge and plenty of ideas and knowledge. It is needed information and helpful content. Thanks so much for sharing. college of education darazo admission 2023

Essien said...


Honestly, it's unique, I appreciate your effort in making out something useful and knowledgeable. Good and intelligent work. Thanks so much for sharing. akwa ibom state school of nursing admission form closing date

hastenchemical said...

Lime kiln dust Florida is commonly used for soil modification and agricultural applications, enhancing soil stability and pH levels. This byproduct of lime production is valued for its cost-effectiveness and ability to improve soil structure in diverse conditions.

Trufleers said...

I recently tried a كراميل ماكياتو, and it was absolutely delightful! The combination of rich espresso and sweet caramel was perfectly balanced, making it a delicious treat. Highly recommended for coffee lovers!

Tomjack said...

An authentic Italian restaurant in Abu Dhabi offers a true taste of Italy with traditional recipes, fresh ingredients, and a warm, inviting ambiance. From handmade pasta to wood-fired pizzas, it’s a go-to spot for genuine Italian dining.

Michlejack25 said...

foundation repair in stony plain focuses on fixing issues like cracks, shifting, or settling caused by soil movement or water damage. Common solutions include crack injections, underpinning, and waterproofing to restore stability. Prompt repairs are essential for maintaining the structural integrity of homes.

Anna Thomas said...

Prof. Marvin Lee Minsky, a pioneer in AI, sadly passed away last night, leaving a profound legacy. For expert services, visit fit out companies Dubai.



new evolution inter deco said...

"We mourn the passing of Prof. Marvin Lee Minsky, a pioneer in artificial intelligence. For expert space transformations, consider the services of a leading fit out company in Abu Dhabi."







smart kitchens said...

italian kitchens in uae are renowned for their elegant design, combining premium materials like marble and wood with modern functionality. These kitchens offer custom cabinetry, sleek finishes, and advanced appliances, reflecting both luxury and efficiency. Perfect for upscale homes, they blend Italian craftsmanship with contemporary style.